Top Places to Eat in Rice Lake, WI

Lehman's Supper Club
There are tons of great restaurants in Rice Lake, WI, but what are the top spots that you can’t miss when you’re visiting Northwest Wisconsin? We’ve assembled a list of our top five Rice Lake restaurants that locals and visitors adore. From tacos to omelettes, learn the very best places to eat in Rice Lake, WI for a memorable meal!

Adventures Restaurant (2901 College Drive)

Adventures Restaurant has the laid-back atmosphere and extensive menu to make any diner feel welcome, so it’s one of the most popular Rice Lake restaurants with Rice Lake visitors. From the New York strip to spicy Thai chicken noodles to the elk steak sandwich, the menu is packed with classic dishes and culinary surprises. Try the signature wild rice meatloaf and don’t miss out on Karen’s famous bread pudding!

Casa Mexicana (421 South Main Street)

Casa Mexicana is a favorite with locals and Hayward foodies alike. Known for bold flavors and innovative cocktails, this restaurant will blow you away with its fresh and flavorful menu. We recommend the fajitas for a sizzling-good dinner, but the burritos are a customer favorite for a big appetite – grab one to-go before you hit the lakes!

Nancy’s Northside Restaurant (930 Haugen Avenue)

Nancy’s Northside Restaurant is a cozy diner where the food is made with love and served with a smile. A staple in the community, this quaint restaurant is the perfect place to grab a bite to eat before you head back to Cumberland. Try the blueberry pancakes for a sweet treat or try a loaded omelette with hash browns for a hearty meal. Plus, Nancy’s serves classic diner fare like burgers and chicken strips if you need a late lunch.

Drag’s Restaurant & Roman Lounge (511 S. Main Street)

Drag’s Restaurant & Roman Lounge serves up Italian classics that make you feel at home, but we think that the pizza is the star of the show. This Rice Lake staple has been producing piping-hot pies for nearly 60 years. Choose between the signature thin crust or try the Sicilian-style with any topping that you can imagine. Try the Drag’s Special or create your own blend!

Lehman’s Supper Club (2911 Main Street)

A family-owned restaurant and cocktail lounge with roots dating back to 1934, Lehman’s Supper Club is one of the single most celebrated restaurants in Rice Lake, WI. This is a great place to kick back and relax in style after a long drive from Rice Lake – and it’s well worth the effort. The steaks are world-class, but options like shrimp scampi and fried frog legs will delight any palate!

Learn More About Rice Lake Restaurants

You know the top restaurants in Rice Lake, WI, but what else should you check out when you’re in our hometown? Contact us at Don Johnson Motors for recommendations and we’ll give you the insider scoop!

More From Don Johnson Motors

  • 2020 Chevy Blazer Colors

    The Chevy Blazer is back, and it’s bolder than ever! It’s sophisticated, yet athletic, exterior is sure to gain more than a few admiring glances on the roads of Rice Lake, and the 2020 Chevy Blazer exterior colors are just one of the many reasons so many people are falling in love with this stellar…

  • 2020 RAM 1500 Trim Levels

    Are you dreaming of driving a new light-duty but tough pickup truck around Rice Lake? If so, check out the 2020 RAM 1500 trim levels. With six trim models starting at only $34,145 MSRP, there’s a vast selection of features, configurations, and prices to choose from. Read more about the 2020 RAM 1500 trim levels below. View…

  • 2020 Ford Ranger Towing Capacity

    Are you looking for a midsize pickup truck in the Rice Lake area that is stylish, bold, and can handle heavy loads? The Ford Ranger’s towing capacity is 7,500 pounds, and the Ranger’s max payload is 1,860 pounds, best in its class! All things considered, the 2020 Ford Ranger is everything that Hayward drivers want in a…

Saved Vehicles ×


You don't have any saved vehicles!

Look for this link on your favorites:


Once you've saved some vehicles, you can view them here at any time.

Contact Us ×

(715) 475-1473

Call Now

734 West Avenue • Rice Lake, WI 54868

Get Directions
[schema type="organization" orgtype="LocalBusiness" url="" name="Don Johnson Motors" description="" street="734 West Avenue" city="Rice Lake" state="WI" postalcode="54868" country="US" email="" phone="(715) 475-1473" logo=""]
Don Johnson Motors
Don Johnson Motors
734 West Avenue
Rice Lake, WI, 54868 US
(715) 475-1473
Don Johnson Motors 45.5080292, -91.7657192.